MoneyHQ Free app

Compare SIM only and phone deals

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
William
Free bill check →
The one decision

Phone deal, or SIM only?

They are two different purchases that happen to share a network. Deciding which one you are making is most of the work.

A phone deal

Handset and airtime in one contract
  • You pay for the handset through the monthly price.
  • Usually 24 or 36 months, sometimes with money upfront.
  • The real cost is the monthly price, the upfront payment and any stated rises, added up over the whole term.
  • Worth comparing when you wanted a new phone anyway.

SIM only

Airtime alone, in the phone you already have
  • Your phone stays; only the SIM and the bill change.
  • From 30-day rolling plans to 24-month contracts.
  • Your number moves with you, by text, in a day.
  • The handset is already paid for, so the whole bill is the airtime.

A rule of thumb we stand behind: if your handset is paid off and still works, SIM only is usually the answer. If you were going to buy a new phone anyway, compare the phone deal against buying the handset outright with a SIM beside it, on the whole-contract cost, not the monthly.

The sums, for 8 popular phones today

Right now the contract works out cheaper for all 8.

PhoneCheaper wayBuy it outrightPlus SIM only, 2 yearsOutright totalCheapest contract, 2 years
iPhone Duo256GB, 15GB dataContract, by £107.20£1,999£144£2,143£2,035.80
iPhone 18 Pro256GB, 15GB dataContract, by £97.20£1,199£144£1,343£1,245.80
iPhone 18 Pro Max256GB, 10GB dataContract, by £77.44£1,299£120£1,419£1,341.56
iPhone Air256GB, 15GB dataContract, by £381.20£1,099£144£1,243£861.80
iPhone 17256GB, 15GB dataContract, by £153.20£899£144£1,043£889.80
iPhone 17e256GB, 15GB dataContract, by £73.20£699£144£843£769.80
iPhone 16128GB, 25GB dataContract, by £277.44£799£168£967£689.56
Samsung Galaxy S26256GB, 10GB dataContract, by £129.44£709£120£829£699.56

How we work it out: the maker’s own UK store price (read 10 November) for the storage the cheapest 24 month contract comes with, plus the cheapest 24 month SIM only plan with at least that contract’s data, against that contract. Upfront costs and every stated price rise are counted, cashback is not taken off, and paying for the phone with credit is not counted. Deals checked 11 November 2026. Each phone’s page has every contract, and William’s guide to buying outright or on contract works the same sums on unlimited data.

Start from what you need

The usual reasons people switch

Each of these lands on the right board with the right question already asked.

  • A lower bill this month →Keep the phone, swap the SIM, keep the number.
  • Unlimited data →Only worth it if you regularly pass 100GB. Most people don’t.
  • A 30-day plan you can leave any month →Flexibility usually costs a pound or two over a contract.
  • Vodafone SIM only deals →Set on Vodafone? Our guide covers the April price rises, the speed caps and how Vodafone compares with EE, Three and O2.
  • O2 SIM only deals →Set on O2? Our guide covers the April price rise on every plan, what O2 Priority and Volt are worth, and how O2 compares with giffgaff, EE and Three.
  • Lebara SIM only deals →Set on Lebara? Our guide covers the international minutes on every plan, EU roaming, eSIM and how Lebara compares with Smarty, VOXI, Lycamobile and Vodafone.
  • Three SIM only deals →Set on Three? Our guide covers the price rises on its fixed plans, rolling plans with no credit check, which plans include roaming, and how Three compares with O2, Vodafone and EE.
  • Lycamobile SIM only deals →Set on Lycamobile? Our guide covers the plans and prices, EE's coverage, what Which? and Trustpilot say, roaming in the EU and India, and how Lyca compares with Rewild, iD Mobile and giffgaff.
  • Spusu SIM only deals →Set on Spusu? Our guide covers the plans and prices, EE's coverage, what Trustpilot says, the price freeze to 2027, EU roaming, and how Spusu compares with Lyca Mobile, SMARTY and Three.
  • Smarty SIM only deals →Set on Smarty? Our guide covers the plans and prices, the network now shared with Vodafone, EU roaming, customer service with no phone line, the credit check, and keeping your number.
  • iD Mobile SIM only deals →Set on iD Mobile? Our guide covers the fixed-price promise, roaming in 50 destinations, Three’s coverage, customer service and Ofcom’s complaints figures, switching with a PAC, and how it compares with Three, SMARTY and O2.
  • A new handset, priced honestly →The phone first, then the contracts available for it.
  • Black Friday phone deals →Each phone’s price against our own nightly record, so a real drop shows.
The whole cost

A monthly price is not the price.

A mobile contract is the monthly price, the upfront payment and any rises the provider has scheduled, added up over the whole term. That is the number the boards will lead with.

Where it adds up

When every part is stated, MoneyHQ shows the whole-contract figure, rises included. A 24-month contract can cross two annual rises; the arithmetic has to include both.

Where it refuses

When a rise is a formula, inflation plus a margin, no one can state the future number today. We show the provider’s own wording and calculate nothing.

Where it is honest

A missing figure stays missing. An unstated upfront cost is not free, and an unstated rise is not a promise the price holds.

Networks, explained

The brand and the masts are different companies.

Many mobile brands rent space on one of the UK’s four mast networks. Same masts, same coverage, different price.

The brand you buy from

Sets the price, the allowance, the contract and the customer service. This is who bills you.

The network it runs on

Owns the masts your phone actually connects to. Two brands on the same host network get you the same signal.

What MoneyHQ shows

Where a brand states its host network, the card says so. Where it does not, the card says nothing rather than guessing.

Price rises

Most contracts get more expensive in April.

Providers state rises three ways, and only two of them can honestly become arithmetic.

A stated schedule

A specific new price from a specific point in the contract. That can be added up, and we will.

A stated yearly increase

A fixed amount or percentage each year from a stated date. Also arithmetic, applied as many times as it lands in your term.

A formula

Inflation plus a margin. Nobody knows next April’s inflation figure, so we show the wording and refuse to invent the number.

Keeping your number?
Switching doesn’t mean starting again. Your number moves with you, usually within one working day. The PAC code guide covers what your old network can charge and what to do if you have already cancelled.
01Text PAC to 65075: your current network replies with a code
02Give the code to your new provider when you order
03Your number moves across, usually the next working day
04The old contract closes itself: no cancellation call needed
MoneyHQ’s position

Most people’s fastest saving in this category is keeping the phone and switching the SIM. The masts stay the same; the price doesn’t. A new handset is a purchase decision, not a savings one, and the boards treat it that way: the phone you want first, then the honest cost of getting it.

Set by William, Founder and deal editor · MoneyHQ makes no recommendation until the figures on a card are verified.
Quick answers
Every Friday
Mobile prices move. We tell you what matters.
The Friday brief covers the changes worth knowing about, in mobile and the rest of your money.
Free · One email a week · Unsubscribe anytime

The Bill Audit

That is one bill. Check the other four.

Tell us what you pay for your broadband, energy, savings and bank account, and we hold each one against deals on sale today and show you the difference, with the working.

Start my audit

Free bill check · Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm

Rather talk to a person?

Book a free 30-minute call with William. Tell him what you pay and how much data you use, and he emails you the links to anything genuinely cheaper.

Book a free call →